Drop ceilings, also known as false ceilings or suspended ceilings, have become a staple of modern architecture. Many basements have ceilings with exposed pipes, wires, and rafters, which can be a very unattractive look. However, drop ceilings are not the only way to beautify your basement ceiling.
There are many alternatives to drop ceilings, including drywall, wooden planks, and corrugated metal. Each option has its pros and cons. Which one you choose depends on your individual needs and the space you are working with. Accessibility, cost, and looks are good to keep in mind when deciding.
Often, the world of DIY home improvement can seem overly complicated and daunting, especially for beginners. In this article, we’ll help you make sense of the different options available for your basement ceiling. Let’s get stuck in!
What Are the Pros and Cons of Drop Ceilings?
Before we get into the alternatives, it is helpful to look at the purpose of drop ceilings to know which boxes the alternatives need to tick. The main purpose of drop ceilings is to cover exposed pipes, wires, and rafters for aesthetic reasons. They also help with soundproofing. Here are some of the pros and cons of drop ceilings:
- Ease of access – This is probably the best reason to have a drop ceiling. While you want to cover up ugly pipes and wires, you also need to get at them for repairs and the like. Options like drywall will make that much more difficult.
- Easy to switch out tiles – If, for example, you decide that you would like your basement to be more soundproof, you can replace the tiles in your drop ceiling with more soundproof ones. This saves you from having to replace the whole ceiling.
- Lower energy requirements – Drop ceilings will lower the height of the ceiling. This leaves you with less space in the basement that you need to heat/cool. The result of this is lower energy bills. So long as there is still enough space to stand up, a lower ceiling actually ends up being a plus.
- Lower ceiling – While a lower ceiling has benefits for your energy bills, you may not want to lose that space. This is especially true if your basement already has low ceilings or if you are a particularly tall person.
- Can deteriorate quickly – drips from the true ceiling can seep into the tiles of your drop ceiling, causing them to become discolored or even moldy. The tiles of a drop ceiling can also sag over time due to a lack of support.
- Aesthetics – Many people do not like how drop ceilings look. I would tend to agree that unless you get interesting tiles, drop ceilings can make your space look like a school or a drab office building.
Okay, now that we have an idea of what the drop ceiling is meant to do, we can move onto the different options you have for replacing it. Each of these options will have benefits and drawbacks, and it is up to you to decide which one is right for your needs and your space.
This is one of the most widespread and cheap options for replacing your drop ceiling. Drywall, also known as gypsum, gives you a smooth and uninterrupted look for your ceiling. It is also one of the cheapest options available. Here are some of the pros and cons of using drywall for your basement ceiling:
- Aesthetics – Many people would agree that a drywall ceiling looks a lot better than a tiled drop ceiling. With no seams or gaps, the drywall’s smooth look makes for a modern and visually appealing ceiling.
- No height degradation – Drywall ceilings do not lower the ceiling’s height nearly as much as a drop ceiling. This makes it a good choice for basements with already low ceilings or already tall inhabitants.
- Easy to install lighting – You can attach lighting directly to drywall ceilings. Alternatively, you can drill holes in the drywall ceiling and install lights flush with the ceiling. This gives the basement a modern and sophisticated look.
- Difficult to access – Unlike drop ceiling tiles, getting in behind a drywall ceiling will be an ordeal! If the pipes you covered up need inspection or repairs, you will have to cut out a section of the ceiling then replace it, which will be tricky and time-consuming.
- Infestations – Drywall ceilings are prone to infestations of pests like ants and termites. This can be expensive and time-consuming to fix. Also, drywall ceilings can easily be damaged by moisture and need to be replaced.
- Easily damaged – As well as being prone to water damage, which requires the drywall to be replaced, these ceilings are also prone to impact damage. That means if you are lifting something tall, you can do serious harm to the drywall ceiling.
Corrugated metal ceilings are by no means a new idea. This is a classic choice that has been revived in recent years thanks to its industrial beauty. Here are some of the pros and cons of a corrugated metal ceiling for your basement:
- Brightens the basement – Corrugated metal ceilings are very reflective compared to many of their rivals. This means that any lighting you use in the basement will go much further! Ideal for a basement with no source of natural light. Plus, fewer lighting requirements also mean a lower energy bill.
- Aesthetics – Many people prefer the industrial look of corrugated metal to the often bland and uninspiring look of a tiled drop ceiling. The metal option will give your ceiling the look of a rustic farm building and goes great with unpainted wooden furniture.
- Energy efficiency – Besides making the ceiling durable and long-lasting, corrugated metal is a great way to keep in the heat and will do a lot to bring down your heating bill during the winter.
- Matches your interior design – Let’s be honest; many interior design choices do not go well with a corrugated metal ceiling. Unless you have already gone for an industrial or rustic look, there is a pretty high chance that metal will not match your look.
- Possibility of rust – Unlike other options, corrugated metal ceilings can rust over time. This, however, can be avoided by properly treating the metal when you install it.
- More expensive than some options – Corrugated metal ceilings can end up costing a fair bit more than other options like drywall or beadboard. However, their longevity and durability mean they can still be an economical choice over time.
Similar to wainscoting, beadboard consists of wooden beams with ridges or ‘beads’ in between. They usually come in large boards that have been fitted together already. Here are some of the pros and cons of the beadboard ceiling in your basement:
- Affordable – Compared to options like corrugated metal and tin tiles, beadboard ends up being one of the cheaper options. It is also relatively easy to install, reducing the cost of labor involved in the process. You can even do it yourself with the right skills.
- Aesthetics – These ceilings can look great if done right! Often painted white, they give the ceiling a textured and neat feel while not being too eye-catching.
- Durability – Beadboard ceilings are much more resistant to water and impact damage than other options like drywall and tiled drop ceilings. Given their low price, that is a big plus!
- Moisture – While beadboard is more resistant to water damage than, say, drywall, it can still be affected by moisture, unlike corrugated metal or tin tiles. Damp beadboards can rot or become moldy, which could mean you have to replace it. This can be quite costly.
- Installation – Unless you are already pretty skilled at carpentry, this can be a tricky DIY project and will likely require a professional to install. However, this applies to many of the ceiling options on this list.
- Hard to access – As mentioned above, a big plus of a drop ceiling is that you can access the pipes and wires you have covered up for repairs and inspection. This won’t be easy to do if you have installed a beadboard in the ceiling.
Painting the Exposed Ceiling
The cheapest option available is also becoming a more popular choice when it comes to looks. Rather than covering up the pipes and rafters, why not just paint them all the same color? This look has become very popular in places like cafés and modern offices. Here are some of the pros and cons of painting the exposed ceiling:
- Cheap – As mentioned already, this will invariably be the most affordable option for you since it doesn’t require professional installation or expensive materials.
- Aesthetics – There is something very appealing about exposed pipes that have been painted a solid color. Black has been a trendy choice in recent years since it doesn’t draw the eye towards the ceiling.
- Quick, easy, and accessible – Not only is this option the quickest and easiest to achieve, but it is also straightforward to access the pipes and wires since they are still exposed. It is a bold statement, but one that can work very well in certain spaces.
- Aesthetics – While the aesthetic appeal was listed as a pro, this look is not for everyone. The bare, exposed look does not suit many interior design choices and will not go well with a polished and neat-looking basement.
- No height reduction – While you probably don’t want your ceiling too much lower, some loss of height can be good since it saves on heating/cooling bills. So long as you can stand upright, the less space, the better for your bills.
- No insulation – Besides having a bigger space to heat, painting the exposed pipes also means nowhere to put in insulation. That can be a problem if you live somewhere that gets cold in the winter.
This option is very similar to beadboard in that it lines the ceiling with neat rows of wooden planks. The main difference is that wooden planks come individually rather than in pre-assembled boards. Here are some of the pros and cons of using wooden planks for the ceiling in your basement:
- Versatile – You have many choices when it comes to a wood plank ceiling. Not only can you choose between different species of wood, but you can also paint and varnish the wood to give it a huge variety of different looks and atmospheres.
- Aesthetics – It is tough to beat the aesthetic appeal of varnished wood. The natural variability of the grain patterns lends an interesting and textured look to the ceiling, making it appear rustic and homely.
- Durability – Wood also offers great durability over time. Although it can warp and rot when wet, it will still hold up far better to both moisture and impact than drywall, which is considered the standard choice to replace a drop ceiling.
- Price – While wooden planks can come in at around the same price as beadboards, how much it will set you back will largely depend on the species of wood you go for. Generally, exotic woods and hardwoods will be more expensive.
- Rot and mold – While wood is durable when it comes to impacts, there is always the possibility of rot and mold. This can be very hard to fix and may require many planks to be replaced entirely. However, this can be avoided with correct wood treatment.
- It does not go with everything – Wooden ceilings go very well with stone but are not a good match for PVC wall panels and other highly artificial looks. Make sure that the material you choose fits in with the existing look of your basement.
Plywood is a great option for many different purposes, and a basement ceiling is no exception. Plywood consists of many layers of processed wood that have been pressed together. Here are some of the pros and cons of a plywood ceiling in your basement:
- Easy access – A plywood board can easily be removed to allow access to pipes and wires for maintenance. This gives it the edge over drywall when it comes to accessibility.
- Durable – Unlike some natural wood species, plywood is resistant to impact damage and water damage like rot and warping. That is because each layer is held together with water-resistant glue.
- Cheap – Plywood is often cheaper than natural (or ‘solid’) woods. If you are not looking for anything too fancy, then this is a great option.
- Aesthetics – Plywood is not as appealing as many solid woods since it lacks the distinctive and beautiful grain patterns found in woods like oak. However, many would agree that it still looks a lot better than a tiled drop ceiling.
- Fire safety – Like all wooden ceilings, plywood has a higher fire risk than some other alternatives like PVC or drywall.
- Cost – While plywood is cheaper than most solid wood alternatives, it is still significantly more expensive than drywall, which is considered the standard option.
Things to Look Out For
Now that we have looked in detail at some of the different options for replacing your drop ceiling, let’s take a look at some of the general considerations:
This one has come up over and over again throughout this article. If you are replacing a drop ceiling, it is a good idea to make sure you can still get at the pipes and wires that are covered up. If you have a leak in a pipe and no way to get at it, you will have to pay not only for the pipe repair but also for the repairs you will have to make to the ceiling itself after cutting into it.
Some of the options described above can get very expensive. Certain types of wood, for example, can end up costing you much more than you might expect. Always make sure to check the price tags of your materials and labor before committing to an idea. This will save you from getting a shock later on.
This one is very much down to personal taste, but it remains an important consideration. This is your space, so you should make it look appealing to you. While wood is hard to beat for looks, the recent move towards industrial-looking designs like corrugated metal or painted exposed pipes has opened up a whole new world of possibilities.
There are tons of options to choose from when it comes to replacing a drop ceiling. I didn’t have space here, for example, to look in detail at tin tiles, PVC, or stretch ceilings. Always make sure you have examined every possibility before committing. Your ceiling will likely not be replaced for quite a while.
I hope this has helped you decide what kind of ceiling you want in your basement. If you keep accessibility, cost, and aesthetics in mind, you should be able to find a great ceiling for your basement.
Best of luck with the renovations!
- Apartment Therapy: Beadboard Vs. Wainscoting: Do You Know the Difference?
- Bob Vila: All You Need to Know About Beadboard Ceilings
- Ceilings By Design: Suspended Ceilings Benefits – 6 Reasons to have a Suspended Ceiling.
- Dea Vita: Metal Ceiling Tiles Pros And Cons – Eye Catching Ceiling Ideas
- Dea Vita: The Advantages of Wood Ceiling in Contemporary Home Interior Design
- Garage Tool Advisor: 10 Cheap Basement Ceiling Ideas for Standard and Low Heights
- Home Stratosphere: 7 Drop Ceiling Alternatives
- How Stuff Works: What Is the Difference Between Drywall and Plaster?
- I Finished My Basement.com: Is a Suspended Ceiling right for your Basement?
- I Finished My Basement.com: Drop Ceiling vs. Drywall for Finishing Your Basement
- Instructables: Ditch the Drywall! Hanging Plywood Ceiling Panels
- Millennial Homeowner: Drop Ceiling or Drywall Ceiling in Basement Which is Best?
- Million Acres: Should You Use Beadboard Ceiling?
- Mullins Company: The Advantages of a Drop Ceiling In Your Basement
- Quartz: The Pros and Cons of Drywall
- The Reno Pros: What Are the Pros and Cons of a Dropped Ceiling?
- Twin Cedars: DIY Basement Ceiling, Beautiful Alternative to Drop-Ceiling
- Whirlwind: What are the Advantages of Metal Ceilings?
- Worst Room: 9 Drop Ceiling Alternatives to Get Away From That Stale Office Look
Share this Post